The Make-Up That Genuinely Deserves Its Reputation
Five high-scoring faces we'd actually repurchase — with the small print you should know first.
Here's the honest truth about testing make-up for a living: after a while, most of it blurs into one big beige haze of 'perfectly fine.' Nothing to text your group chat about. Nothing that makes you do a little mirror double-take. So when something scores above an 8.5 in the Glow Lab, we genuinely sit up and pay attention. These five earned their marks — not because they're flawless (nothing is, and anyone who tells you otherwise is selling something), but because they do what they promise well enough that we'd buy them again with our own money. I'm celebrating each one properly, but I'm also telling you the catch — because you deserve to know before you part with your cash.
Rare Beauty Soft Pinch Liquid Blush
For anyone who wants cheeks that look lit from within — one reviewer called it 'a filter IRL' and they're spot on. It blends beautifully and lasts all day, but the pigmentation is so intense that shade-matching blind is a genuine gamble.
Read the full verdict →
Maybelline Sky High Mascara
For length-chasers on a budget who want lashes that actually look longer, not just spidery. The catch is the burgundy shade is lovely in theory but barely registers on darker lashes — grab the black if you want drama.
Read the full verdict →
no makeup
For those chasing that 'your skin but calmer' aesthetic, this is the concept everyone's riffing on — and when it works, it's gorgeous. The catch is the shade range and accessibility issues mean it's still not the universal holy grail its fans wish it was.
Read the full verdict →
Fenty Beauty Pro Filt'r Soft Matte Foundation
For oily and combination skin types who want matte without the mask — this genuinely shifted the industry's approach to shade ranges. The catch is dry patches will be highlighted ruthlessly, so exfoliate first or look elsewhere.
Read the full verdict →
Charlotte Tilbury Pillow Talk Lipstick
For anyone wanting a polished nude that reads sophisticated rather than 2016-Kardashian — it's creamy, flattering on many tones, and the dupes exist for a reason. The catch is the hype can overshadow reality; some will try it and wonder what the fuss was about.
Read the full verdict →